Celebrating 40 Shaken Baby Syndrome Exonerations

Thousands of people have been convicted in Shaken Baby Syndrome cases. Forty of those have been exonerated to date—officially cleared of wrongdoing. Few received official apologies for the devastation of their lives. Some were escorted out of prison doors and left to fend for themselves with no money, job, housing, or insurance.

The National Registry of Exonerations estimates that about 41% of exonerees who seek compensation for a wrongful conviction receive it, but the process can be long and frustrating. No amount of money can erase the suffering these people endured. Families were bankrupted, children torn from their parents’ arms. Some exonerees were not allowed to attend their baby’s funeral. They were locked behind bars when their kids took first steps, started kindergarten, celebrated special birthdays, starred in the school play, won a medal in sports, walked down the aisle to marry the person they love. They missed good night hugs, family vacations, being at their mother’s bedside when she died. The divorce rate for couples when one spouse is in jail or prison for more than a year is 80% to 90%.

At least 90 additional people whose convictions were overturned took plea bargains to time served to end the nightmare. They chose to recover whatever shattered remnants of their lives remained rather than fight on. They’d learned that innocence is no excuse when the allegation is child abuse.

These 40 exonerees spent a grand total of nearly 340 YEARS behind prison walls! One had been sentenced to death, four to life without parole. Five were sentenced to life with possible parole, and another four to indeterminate sentences of decades to life, which effectively means life unless guilt is acknowledged. Parole boards have little sympathy for convicts who refuse to admit culpability.

Click anywhere on a line to read an exoneree’s complete story on the National Registry of Exonerations web site.  A 2-page printable list is here.

Name
Location
Incident
Conviction
Sentence
Exoneration
Years Served
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Joshua Burns
Brighton, MI
03/15/2014
01/27/2015
1 year
11/21/2024
1
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Andrew Roark
DeSoto, TX
07/16/1997
03/24/2000
35 years
10/09/2024
12.7
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Alan Butts
Westerville, OH
02/13/2002
03/11/2003
Life
02/12/2024
19.5
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Michael Griffin
Flint, MI
09/30/2009
07/23/2010
Life no parole
09/13/2023
14
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Christopher Lyman
Junction City, KS
09/15/2013
05/04/2015
Life
07/18/2023
8.2
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Jennifer Del Prete
Romeoville, IL
12/27/2002
03/04/2005
20 years
10/05/2022
9
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Kim Hoover-Moore
Columbus, OH
11/29/2002
11/07/2003
15 years to life
10/21/2021
18
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Terry Lee Ceasor
Port Huron, MI
10/03/2004
12/19/2005
2 to 15 years
09/30/2021
4
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Tonia Miller
Battle Creek, MI
10/19/2001
04/14/2003
20 to 30 years
04/08/2021
18
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Shawn Brown Sr.
Battle Creek, MI
01/22/2010
08/18/2010
8 to 30 years
04/08/2021
10.6
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Clarence Jones III
Woodlawn, MD
08/25/1998
03/04/1999
30 years
12/01/2020
18
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Dane Krukowski
Saginaw, MI
02/10/2015
05/06/2016
3 to 10 years
11/20/2020
3.3
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Codie Lynn Stevens
Saginaw, MI
02/10/2015
05/06/2016
3 to 10 years
11/20/2020
3.3
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Randy Liebich
Willowbrook, IL
02/08/2002
07/16/2004
65 years
04/17/2019
16.5
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Vicente Benavides
Delano, CA
11/17/1991
04/20/1993
Death
04/19/2018
27 years
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Zavion Johnson
Sacramento, CA
11/24/2001
12/12/2002
25 years to life
01/19/2018
17
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Krystal Voss
Alamosa, CO
01/31/2003
11/09/2004
20 years
09/08/2017
13
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Jasmine Eskew
Great Falls, MT
09/18/2012
04/01/2014
5 years
02/28/2017
4.5
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Derrick Allen
Durham, NC
02/09/1998
08/26/1999
43 to 54 years
10/25/2016
12
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Derick Epps
Haverhill, MA
10/09/2004
07/28/2007
7 to 10 years
07/14/2016
6
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Gregory Council Jr.
Jacksonville, FL
07/29/2009
06/29/2011
30 years
12/11/2014
4.1
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
LeeVester Brown
Clarksdale, MS
03/28/2003
08/11/2006
Life no parole
12/11/2014
8.5
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Adrian Thomas
Troy, NY
09/19/2008
10/23/2009
25 years to life
06/12/2014
4.6
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Drayton Witt
Phoenix, AZ
06/01/2000
02/26/2002
20 years
10/31/2012
12.4
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Julie Baumer
Mt. Clemens, MI
10/03/2003
09/29/2005
10 to 15 years
10/16/2010
5
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Melonie Ware
Decatur, GA
03/18/2004
11/10/2005
Life
10/06/2009
.75
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Audrey Edmunds
Waunakee, WI
10/16/1995
10/26/1996
18 years
07/11/2008
11
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Warren Hales
Midvale, UT
12/05/1985
07/08/2004
Life
06/15/2007
1
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Donna Conley
Saltillo, OH
12/17/1996
07/16/2003
13
05/18/2007
3.8
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Claude Morings Jr.
Eure, NC
06/01/2001
06/01/2002
.5
06/01/2006
.5
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Brandy Briggs
Houston, TX
05/05/1999
10/02/2000
17 years
12/16/2005
5
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Abigail Tiscareño
Park City, UT
11/14/2003
10/28/2004
Not sentenced
05/27/2005
0
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Ken Marsh
San Diego, CA
04/27/1983
11/28/1983
15 years to life
10/10/2004
21
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
John Peel Sr.
St. Petersburg, FL
06/27/1998
12/12/2000
10 years
10/16/2002
4
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Terrance Washington Sr.
Tallahassee, FL
12/04/1996
06/04/1997
Life no parole
08/31/2001
4.7
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Letha Jean Hockersmith
Sand Springs, OK
05/17/1992
04/18/1994
Life
05/25/1999
2.5
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Joel Lehmer
Council Bluffs, IA
04/04/1997
10/02/1997
15 years
09/23/1998
.9
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Theresa Engberg-Lehmer
Council Bluffs, IA
04/04/1997
10/02/1997
15 years
09/23/1998
.9
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Mary Weaver
Marshalltown, IA
01/22/1993
03/22/1994
Life no parole
03/05/1997
2.8
Name
Location
Incident Date
Conviction Date
Sentencing
Exoneration Date
Years Served
Sean Ralston
Ayer, MA
10/05/1984
03/08/1989
10 to 15 years
06/15/1992
3